Quick answer: Choose an AHA (glycolic, lactic or mandelic acid) if your main concerns are dullness, rough texture, uneven tone or sun-related fine lines. Choose a BHA (salicylic acid) if you have oily skin, blackheads or breakouts, because it is oil-soluble and works inside pores. Choose a PHA (gluconolactone or lactobionic acid) if your skin is dry or sensitive and stings with other acids. Whichever you pick, start two or three nights a week and wear sunscreen daily, since AHAs measurably increase sun sensitivity.
This guide is for anyone standing in front of a shelf of toners, serums and peel pads trying to work out which acid to buy, or for people who already use one and want to know whether a different acid would suit them better. It explains how each type works, who it suits, how often to use it and how to avoid irritation. This guide is general information, not medical advice; see a board-certified dermatologist for persistent acne, pigmentation or skin sensitivity.
What chemical exfoliants do
Your skin naturally sheds dead cells from its surface, but the process can slow down or become uneven, leaving skin looking dull and rough and pores more prone to clogging. Chemical exfoliants loosen the bonds that hold those dead cells together so they shed more evenly. The American Academy of Dermatology (AAD) describes chemical exfoliation as using agents such as alpha and beta hydroxy acids to dissolve dead skin cells, as opposed to mechanical exfoliation with scrubs, brushes or pads.
The three families differ mainly in molecule size and whether they dissolve in water or oil. Those two traits decide how deep and how fast an acid works, and how likely it is to sting.
AHAs: glycolic, lactic and mandelic acid
Alpha hydroxy acids are mostly water-soluble and work on the skin’s surface. They are the best-studied option for texture, dullness, uneven tone and the fine lines that come with sun damage. A 2024 review in Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology notes that AHAs are used for acne, hyperpigmentation and photoaging, and that molecule size affects how they behave.
- Glycolic acid has the smallest molecule, so it penetrates quickly and works fastest. Cleveland Clinic calls it strong and potentially irritating, and suggests starting once or twice a week at night.
- Lactic acid is gentler and also acts as a moisturizer, according to Cleveland Clinic. It is a common pick for dry skin and is often used in body lotions for keratosis pilaris, the rough bumps on the upper arms.
- Mandelic acid is a larger molecule. The 2024 review notes that larger AHAs like mandelic acid are less likely to cause irritation, which makes it a frequent choice for sensitive or acne-prone skin.
For leave-on cosmetic products, the US Cosmetic Ingredient Review panel considered glycolic and lactic acid safe at concentrations of 10 percent or less with a final pH of 3.5 or higher, as summarized by the FDA. Stronger peels belong in a professional setting.
BHA: salicylic acid
Salicylic acid is the main beta hydroxy acid in skincare. It is oil-soluble, so it can move through sebum and into pores. A review in Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology describes it as lipophilic, able to concentrate in the oil glands, and comedolytic, meaning it helps clear blackheads and whiteheads.
- Best for: oily and combination skin, blackheads, whiteheads and mild breakouts.
- Strength: in the US, salicylic acid is an approved over-the-counter acne ingredient at 0.5 to 2 percent.
- Frequency: Cleveland Clinic notes that it is not overly irritating for most people and that many can use it up to twice a day, but drier skin may need less.
- Cautions: salicylic acid is closely related to aspirin. The salicylic acid review notes that salicylic acid peels are not recommended in pregnancy for that reason. If you are pregnant, allergic to aspirin or using large amounts on the body, ask your doctor first.
If oil and pores are your main concern, pairing a BHA with a niacinamide serum is a common approach; our guide to niacinamide serums for oily skin explains how to combine them.
PHAs: gluconolactone and lactobionic acid
Polyhydroxy acids are chemically related to AHAs but have larger molecules with more water-attracting groups. A review in Cutis reports that PHAs provide effects similar to AHAs without the sensory irritation that limits classic AHAs, that they have been found compatible with clinically sensitive skin, including rosacea and atopic dermatitis, and that they add moisturizing benefits.
- Best for: dry, sensitive or reactive skin, people who sting with glycolic acid, and beginners.
- Trade-off: they work more slowly and gently, so results on texture and tone take longer.
- Sun sensitivity: in a small study in Dermatologic Surgery, gluconolactone did not significantly increase sunburn cells in human skin after UV exposure. That is one study, so daily sunscreen is still the rule.
AHA vs. BHA vs. PHA at a glance
| AHA | BHA | PHA | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Common forms | Glycolic, lactic, mandelic | Salicylic | Gluconolactone, lactobionic |
| Dissolves in | Water (mostly) | Oil | Water |
| Where it works | Skin surface | Surface and inside pores | Skin surface, more slowly |
| Best for | Dullness, rough texture, uneven tone, sun-related fine lines | Oily skin, blackheads, whiteheads, mild acne | Dry, sensitive or reactive skin |
| Irritation potential | Moderate (glycolic highest, mandelic lowest) | Low to moderate | Low |
| Sun sensitivity | Increased; FDA recommends a sunburn alert | Use sunscreen as with any exfoliant | Not significant in one small study |
| Typical starting frequency | 1 to 2 nights a week | Every other day | 2 to 3 nights a week |
Sun sensitivity: why sunscreen is non-negotiable
The FDA’s page on alpha hydroxy acids summarizes a study in which four weeks of AHA use increased skin’s sensitivity to UV-induced reddening by 18 percent and roughly doubled sensitivity to UV-induced cell damage on average, with large differences between people. The effect was reversible: a week after stopping, there was no significant difference.
That is why the FDA recommends a sunburn alert on AHA products telling users to wear sunscreen, cover up and limit sun exposure while using the product and for a week afterward. Cleveland Clinic recommends SPF 30 or higher daily with any facial acid. Using acids at night helps with comfort, but it does not remove the need for sunscreen the next day.
How often to exfoliate, and how to start
- Pick one acid based on your main concern, not three.
- Start two or three nights a week (once or twice for glycolic), on clean, dry skin, followed by moisturizer.
- Increase slowly over several weeks if your skin stays comfortable. The AAD notes that the more aggressive the method, the less often you should use it.
- Watch for warning signs. The AAD says red, irritated skin means you have overdone it. Stinging that lasts, tightness and flaking are reasons to scale back.
- Expect some adjustment. Cleveland Clinic notes that some purging, or temporary breakouts, can occur for a few weeks, but stinging, itching or redness are not normal.
Avoid exfoliating on sunburned, broken or freshly waxed skin. If you also use vitamin C, our guide to vitamin C serums covers how to keep it in the morning and acids at night.
Can you combine acids with retinoids and other actives?
You can use both, but usually not at the same time. The AAD cautions that combining exfoliation with retinoids or benzoyl peroxide can worsen dryness or trigger breakouts. Common ways to separate them:
- Alternate nights: acid one night, retinoid another, with plain moisturizer nights in between. This is the logic behind skin cycling.
- Use salicylic acid in the morning and a retinoid at night, if your skin tolerates both.
- Do not layer several acids. Products that already combine an AHA and a BHA count as one acid step.
Who should skip acids or see a dermatologist
- Darker skin tones or a history of dark marks. The AAD says aggressive exfoliation can increase pigmentation in some people with darker skin. Mandelic acid or a PHA at low frequency is a gentler starting point, and a dermatologist can advise.
- Rosacea, eczema or a damaged barrier. Repair first, then try a PHA if a dermatologist agrees.
- Prescription retinoid or acne treatment users. Ask your prescriber before adding an acid.
- Pregnancy. Ask your obstetrician, especially about salicylic acid.
- Persistent acne, melasma or scarring. Over-the-counter acids are mild; a dermatologist has stronger, better-targeted options.
Our take
There is no best acid, only the best match for your skin. If you want smoother, brighter skin and tolerate actives, a lactic or glycolic acid a few nights a week is the classic choice. If breakouts and blackheads are the issue, salicylic acid is the logical pick because it reaches into pores. If everything stings, start with a PHA or mandelic acid. Use one acid at a time, build up slowly, keep a plain moisturizer nearby, and treat daily sunscreen as part of the product.
Sources
- FDA: Alpha hydroxy acids in cosmetics
- Cleveland Clinic: A guide to facial acids
- American Academy of Dermatology: How to safely exfoliate at home
- 21 CFR 333.310: Acne active ingredients
- Almeman, Evaluating the efficacy and safety of alpha-hydroxy acids in dermatological practice (Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol, 2024)
- Arif, Salicylic acid as a peeling agent: a comprehensive review (Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol, 2015)
- Grimes et al., The use of polyhydroxy acids (PHAs) in photoaged skin (Cutis, 2004)
- Bernstein et al., The polyhydroxy acid gluconolactone protects against ultraviolet radiation in an in vitro model of cutaneous photoaging (Dermatol Surg, 2004)
Frequently asked questions
Can I use AHA and BHA together?
Many products combine them, and that counts as one exfoliating step. Using a separate AHA and BHA on the same night raises the risk of irritation, so most people do better alternating them or using salicylic acid in the morning and an AHA at night only if their skin tolerates it.
Which exfoliating acid is best for sensitive skin?
PHAs such as gluconolactone and lactobionic acid are generally the gentlest, followed by mandelic and lactic acid. Start with two or three nights a week, and stop if you get lasting stinging, redness or flaking.
Do I need sunscreen if I only use acids at night?
Yes. The FDA reports that AHA use increased sensitivity to UV damage in a study, and it recommends sun protection while using AHAs and for a week after stopping. Night use does not remove that effect.
Is salicylic acid safe during pregnancy?
Salicylic acid is closely related to aspirin, and salicylic acid peels are generally not recommended during pregnancy. Ask your obstetrician before using any salicylic acid product while pregnant.
How long does it take to see results from an exfoliating acid?
Skin may feel smoother within a few uses, but changes in tone, texture and breakouts usually take several weeks of consistent use. Some people get temporary breakouts for a few weeks when starting, which is different from stinging or redness.

